I’d give CAPTAIN MARVEL a strong “B” for “bueno”– not particularly great or deeply compelling emotionally, but filled with color and action-filled fun. Some of the villainous characters were interesting. Samuel Jackson as Agent Fury portrays a pleasant mix of gritty and humorous, stealing almost every scene that he’s in. His character is more developed here than in any of the previous Marvel productions. I was glad to get to know his back story and what makes him tick as a person.
The editing is rather choppy in places, fitting in a lot in a little over two hours. It took a second viewing (this time with my husband) to follow the whole story more clearly. Also, the ending was anti-climactic, fizzling down into an almost comical, very brief fight for Carol Danvers/Captain Marvel against a powerful man who had deeply deceived her.
I’ve never seen a house cat used so creatively in a film before, so that was something extra entertaining.
I am heartened to see another comic book movie about a super heroine, and one who was originally created as a male no less. It’s important to keep switching up things in favor of showcasing more powerful, heroic women– so long overdue. But, for my personal taste, I find other Marvel and DC super heroines thus far portrayed on screen to be much more charismatic than Brie Larson’s Captain Marvel. Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman and Scarlett Johansson as Black Widow come readily to mind. However, I give Ms. Larson an “A” for effort, even if she often did not feel like a gripping, dynamic character to me. She lacked some edge and emotional depth. Larson’s Carol Danvers/Captain Marvel was very much in the Americana trope of ordinary-seeming, “apple pie” wholesome, someone I could more readily envision surfing the waves in Southern California rather than fighting off heavily-armed aliens and spaceships.
Frankly, other people came to mind as a more believable Captain Marvel. I would have preferred Lashana Lynch, who plays the lead’s best friend, in the title role. But, Ms. Lynch’s being African American relegated her to a supporting player, I guess– at least this time around. I so wish the two characters for the actresses had been reversed, though even that change may have only partially worked better for me. Interestingly, after we’d watched the movie, my husband said he imagined the singer and occasional actress Pink (Alecia Moore) being great in the part, although she is now ten years too old to play it. I definitely could see a younger Pink as Carol Danvers/Captain Marvel, for she’s definitely a woman with some chutzpah and believable emotional intensity.
These super heroine/hero movie roles have big boots to fill. It’s disappointing when casting is off the mark for any of them, like Ben Affleck as Batman has been. Same goes for Brie Larson in this latest Marvel blockbuster– though, to be fair, not quite that disappointing. All said and done, I will be okay with watching her in the upcoming AVENGERS: ENDGAME. Perhaps Ms. Larson will grow into her role more, particularly with such an ensemble of comparative heavy-weights for her to have to mesh with. There is possibly that.